The Story
BEFORE
When she came to us, she had built something that every large city should have. NYC Brunch Squad was an actual community for millennial and Gen Z women to make friends and attend private events in NYC, with a super engaged Instagram following and an average of around 100 new members joining per month. On paper, that looked like a thriving business.
But she had run into the problem most founders with growing audiences quietly run into. When a platform is working well enough, it's easy to assume that's where the business should live. The audience is there, the engagement is real, the growth is steady. But "working well enough" and "where your actual buyer lives" are two different things. There's almost always a platform the business hasn't tapped yet where the ideal client is already having the exact conversation the business solves, and the founder isn't in the room because the current platform feels like it's doing the job.
That was where this brand was stuck. The whole strategy was running on one platform, and it wasn't the right one for her ideal member:
Her audience was already in a room she wasn't in.
But she had run into the problem most founders with growing audiences quietly run into. When a platform is working well enough, it's easy to assume that's where the business should live. The audience is there, the engagement is real, the growth is steady. But "working well enough" and "where your actual buyer lives" are two different things. There's almost always a platform the business hasn't tapped yet where the ideal client is already having the exact conversation the business solves, and the founder isn't in the room because the current platform feels like it's doing the job.
That was where this brand was stuck. The whole strategy was running on one platform, and it wasn't the right one for her ideal member:
- Instagram was her only marketing channel, with engaged followers but limited reach into her actual demographic
- Her ideal member, Gen Z and millennial women living in NYC, was overwhelmingly on TikTok, not Instagram
- The conversations her ideal member was already having, about how hard it is to make friends in the city and where to actually find them, were happening on TikTok
- She personally didn't use TikTok and had been hesitant for months to start posting there
- The growth was steady but stuck. 100 members a month was the best case, not the breakthrough case.
Her audience was already in a room she wasn't in.